Haiti leader has doubts about OAS report: official

By Joseph Guyler Delva and Allyn Gaestel

PORT-AU-PRINCE | Thu Jan 13, 2011 7:13pm EST

PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) – Haitian President Rene Preval has reservations about a report from a regional organization that challenges the official results of Haiti’s chaotic November elections, an official said on Thursday.

Preval, who cannot himself stand for a second consecutive term, on Thursday received the report by the team of Organization of American States experts, which recommends that a government-backed presidential candidate be eliminated from a second-round run-off election.

“The president has a number of reservations on the methodology the members of the (OAS) commission used to get to their conclusions,” said the senior government official, who asked not to be identified.

The OAS report challenges the official preliminary results from Haiti’s November 28 national elections.

Preval’s reported doubts about the report could stir political tensions and uncertainty a day after Haiti commemorated the first anniversary of the devastating January 12 2010 earthquake in the poor, volatile Caribbean country.

The president, whom opponents have accused of rigging the U.N.-backed November elections that took place amid widespread confusion and fraud allegations, had originally asked the OAS to help verify the disputed preliminary election results.

It was not clear whether Preval would reject the report’s recommendation or seek to discuss his reservations further with the OAS experts.

The preliminary election results, which were hotly contested by opposition candidates and triggered streets riots when they were announced by the Provisional Electoral Council last month, had put government technocrat and Preval protege Jude Celestin in the second round.

The OAS experts’ report cited “significant” vote tally irregularities to recommended that Celestin be replaced in the second round run-off by popular musician Michel Martelly, who had been narrowly placed third in the preliminary results.

In a meeting on Thursday with Colin Granderson, head of a joint OAS/Caribbean Community mission that observed the elections, Preval also expressed anger at the fact that the report by the seven OAS electoral experts had been leaked on Monday to a U.S. media organization, the official said.

He added Preval’s reservations also focused on the fact that six of the seven members of the OAS team came either from the United States, Canada or France, countries which had raised early public objections to the preliminary Haiti election results. The seventh member of the team was from Jamaica.


The OAS experts’ report confirmed opposition matriarch Mirlande Manigat as the candidate who won most votes in the first round, although she did not gain enough to win outright. She therefore remains in the second-round run-off.

It was not immediately clear if Preval would submit the OAS recommendation to the Provisional Electoral Council, the final arbiter of the elections.

Election observers say that even if the council heeds the OAS experts’ findings, it still has to complete a disputes procedure before it can formally announce final revised results from the November 28 first round vote.

This means Haiti will not be able to hold a presidential election second round run-off before February, at the earliest.

Edmond Mulet, head of the U.N. peacekeeping force in Haiti, stressed the importance of adhering to Haiti’s constitution in comments to reporters on Thursday. He voiced hope that the electoral impasse would soon be resolved.

“Political stability, is essential. Respect for the constitution, respect for the law, can attract investment,” Mulet said.

The protests and violence which followed the December 7 preliminary results raised fears that instability could delay the handover of billions of dollars of urgently needed reconstruction funds for Haiti from foreign donors.

(Additional reporting by Allyn Gaestel; Writing by Pascal Fletcher and Tom Brown; Editing by Xavier Briand)


Author: `

2 thoughts on “Haiti leader has doubts about OAS report: official

  1. Here we go again.

    This OAS team has taken a pile of ballots that may or may not have been in the ballot boxes and now try to weave these into some sort of result.

    The same evidence would be thrown out of an American/Canadian court on the basis that there was “no chain of evidence…” No one can swear that the ballots today are those of yesterday, or the day before. They sat unsupervised for weeks.

    Now the OAS is trying to force Mirlande Manigat, a person in ill-health and who possesses few real supporters, upon a helpless nation. The CEP picked Manigat because Preval believed he could control her. He had given her a substantial sum of money – millions – and a promise of support through the second round of voting.

    Preval would name her cabinet, prime minister and control the Parliament.

    We have already suffered a fixed election in 2005 when Brazil/Chile in MINUSTAH increased Preval’s 23% to 51% and avoided a run-off that would have seen Charles Baker as the winner.

    Preval must go.

    A new CEP must be named.

    The International Community must fund and supervise the process to guarantee a fair result.

    And let the people pick their own president.

  2. I wonder where are the laws when one man is playing with all of u.how incompetant have haitian educated ones become.
    at the same time, the haiatian people are very patient to accept the stupidities of only one man called Rene Preval. who block the process of any possible reconstruction, develpement aid to ge out of costume and so on.
    so u tell me how long are u going to let Preval play with u?

Comments are closed.