Why Black People Understand Rachel Jeantel by Christina Coleman and Many Whites Don’t

June 27, 2013 by Christina Coleman for Global Grind Staff

If ever I thought myself objective and unbiased, the George Zimmerman trial is definitely not that moment.

So let’s cut to the chase. Any attorney, jury member, judge or white person in that courtroom is not going to understand Rachel Jeantel. And I don’t expect them to.

In fact, I certainly, like my fellow writer Rachel Samara, understand why white people wouldn’t like Rachel.

She’s hard. She’s black. And your assumptions about her background and lack of education make you feel like you are better, somehow. That her testimony, no matter how powerful and impactful it may be to this trial, is implausible. Weak, maybe? Let’s impeach her.

But maybe the reason white people don’t understand Rachel Jeantel has something more to do with white privilege then, what they would call, Rachel’s capricious nature.

Let’s for one second try to understand why Rachel is “angry” (read emotional), “hood” (read blunt), and “unintelligent” (read multilingual).

The thing is, what white people see in Rachel has little to do about her own issues, and more to say about the America that white people are blind to. Let’s take her testimony on not calling the police, for example.

Rachel told defense attorney Don West that she didn’t call the police after she heard the scuffle between Trayvon Martin and the man that was following him for numerous reasons. First, she believed that he was right near his “daddy’s house,” and that Tracy would help him. She also was under the impression that, if it were a life or death situation, someone would certainly come to his aid. But as West continued his questioning, riddled with nuances to throw Rachel off track, the glaring subtext of this all became clear.

Don West doesn’t understand why Rachel didn’t call the police when she heard a struggle. Rachel, who is a black woman, doesn’t call the police. Why? Black people and police officers don’t mix.

The tottering seesaw between black people and law enforcement leaves us in a position where we are afraid to call the cops because we’re not exactly sure they are on our side. And in an age where police responding to calls for help will still result in an innocent black person’s incarceration or death, it’s difficult to know who to trust or turn to during times of need.

Distrust in police stems from decades of being disenfranchised and treated unfairly by those who were supposed to protect us. And yes, I’m taking it there…distrust in white people. Government. LAPD. NYPD. Most recently, the White Plains police department in Westchester County, NY who murdered an innocent black man named Kenneth Chamberlain when his Life Aid medical necklace was inadvertently triggered and they were summoned to his home. And just last week, the police officer in Detroit, Michigan who shot and killed 7-year-old Aiyana Jones was set free after a mistrial. Not to mention the killers of Amadou Diallo or the torturers of Abner Louiama.

The point is, black people can understand Rachel’s hesitancy when it came to contacting the police because the fear and doubt that comes with dealing with law enforcement is as entwined into the tapestry of our culture as is our slavery past.

It’s not that Rachel can’t be trusted. In fact, her testimony has remained solid and consistent throughout her nearly seven hours of questioning.

But, the initial fear of not knowing what would happen is something that black people can understand. And overlook. Which is something that someone with white privilege wouldn’t exactly grasp.

But what’s more are the cultural differences between white and black people.

When asked why she omitted the words “creepy ass cracker” and “nigga” when speaking in front of Sybrina Fulton about her son’s last moments, she simply told the court that she didn’t want to disrespect her.

As West looked at her in utter disbelief, Rachel looked back, unwavering. How could he not understand that she couldn’t bring herself to upset someone who had just lost a child? Better yet, curse in front of adults.

Note: Disrespect to elders in the black and especially Caribbean communities is almost as bad as cursing the Lord.

And speaking of that word “nigga,” the court might not understand Trayvon and Rachel’s casual use of the word because of how often, no matter how controversial, it is used in our communities.

So aside from the argument that we took the power out of a degrading word and made it into a term of endearment, it’s used so much that it’s become a substitute for identifiers such as “that guy,” or “him,” etc.

And for Don West to argue that the use of the word “nigga” was racial for Trayvon is incomprehensible, especially because he used it on a person who was not of African descent.

For Rachel, these little cultural differences get lost in translation. And instead of trying to understand her, people are reducing the miscommunication to semantics, what they call her broken “Kings English,” and her anger. Without even realizing that she comes from a home where Creole is her first language, or that her friend was killed just seconds after he last spoke to her. Wouldn’t you be frustrated in front of a court that refuses to understand you?

But most importantly, if there is anything that black people can understand that those judging her are not, it’s the loss of life without justice.

And as Rachel Jeantel sits on the stand, nervous, mumbling and annoyed, it’s not that she’s just a “hoodrat with no media training from a hostile environment.”

It’s just that your world and our world are…excuse the cliche…worlds apart.

And that, my friends, was never Rachel Jeantel’s fault.

Christina Coleman

Christina Coleman is the News and Politics Editor at GlobalGrind and a Howard University Alumna. Prior to this she was a science writer. That explains her NASA obsession. She crushes on Anthony Bourdain. Nothing explains that. Follow her on Twitter @ChrissyCole for all things news & politics. Oh. And afros.


Author: `

6 thoughts on “Why Black People Understand Rachel Jeantel by Christina Coleman and Many Whites Don’t

  1. Thank you for this illuminating article. Conversations yesterday among a group of us white folk of several “ethnic” backgrounds revealed everyone without exception was outraged about the treatment of Ms. Jeantel. Your article clearly articulates for us some of the deep, old, sharp edges that are lacerating this grieving friend.

  2. a teenager is dead and were focusing on the weight and diction of a witness instead of the fact this boy is gone and they have been trying to discredit him and basically say “he deserved it” since the beginning.

    trayvon is gone and zimmerman is alive, yet they stil try and find reasons to blame him because it couldn’t have been that Zimmerman just assaulted this yo ung black man for no reason right? he had to do something. so they pulled his school records, talked to people that knew him, and now i this young lady.

    It’s just sickening that the gross injustice of why this man isn’t in jail a year later isn’t the issue,this has dragged on and instead people are focusing on this young woman’s weight and how she speaks. this is what i mean when i hear black people of all ethnicities.. african american, west indian, african , what have you squabble and insult each other, this is what i mean, at the end of the day, you are black in the eyes of this country no matter yo ur origins so it its so silly to insult other black ethnic groups, all of us who thought we were “too good” have seen it happen in our communities, Ethiopian, Guinean, Haitian (remember Abner Louima) li ka timoun fre, pè ou sè nou ki yo rete oubyen tchouye tankou bet.

  3. White people have not changed at all after all of these integration and civil rights laws, and the Whites had failed to responsibly bring the Blacks into the Main Stream, as Citizens that are equal under the Law.

    The Whites had completely violated all charter of voted and establishing laws in this Country, they do as they pleased with total contempt and disregard for any other citizen when their racial interest is at the bargaining table, what a bunch of hypocrites and backstabbers, creeps.

    1. Yep- you are part of the problem-As a Spaniard, I think the problem today is on BOTH sides of the fence. Black and White. You are both part of the problem.


  4. Why can’t All Blacks return to Africa, and all Whites return to Europe World over?//and no more International trespassing, no more relations, interaction between the races, Whites should only mind their own territories, skies and waters, the Black should stop wandering around into white lands, in search of something better that never came, they should stay in Africa to work their lands, no more United Nations, FMI, WorldBank.

    1. MEK POK- I have a question for you- Why don’t all of the Bigots go jump off a cliff? Your other three comments are deleted due to the blatantly racist perspective.

Comments are closed.