An Aristide government would put Haiti in Hugo Chavez camp-Added COMMENTARY By Haitian-Truth

By RAY WALSER

Seven months after the tragic Jan. 12 earthquake, Haiti is at last on the path to reconstruction. Thanks to a substantial flood of assistance, with billions of dollars more promised, the minimal needs of the Haitian people are finally being met. Yet the pace of recovery is painfully slow.

The United States and the world have their sights set upon on a Haiti-owned process for building a new, sustainable, productive island nation. Yet in a country where 80 percent of the populace lives on less than $2 a day and where hundreds of thousands live in tents, rough sketches of a better future are still on the drawing boards.

Haiti’s future depends on how well its people can preserve political patience, mobilize massively to succeed and steer an essentially reformist course. A better Haiti requires sustained cooperation between rich, middle class and poor.

It also requires an ability to work with the complex maze of international bodies: the United Nations, non-governmental organizations, and key donors like Brazil, Canada, France and the United States.

Generally idealistic, sometimes cynical and always bureaucratic, this patchwork of forces provides the safety net that keeps Haiti from falling into the abyss. Without sustained international support, Haiti will collapse.

Elections on Nov. 28 offer the chance to select post-earthquake leadership with a mandate to build a new Haiti. They also pose a risk that political divisions will further fracture the nation.

Thus far, more than three dozen potential candidates say they will contest the presidency. The hopefuls range from hip-hop star Wyclef Jean to Yvon Neptune, an ally of former President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Electoral experts point out the fact that conditions in post-earthquake Haiti present immense registration and polling challenges.

One leader, currently removed from the Haitian scene, could easily make the devastated country again ungovernable.

The controversial Aristide is viewed as a pivotal Haitian political figure. His machinations and incendiary leadership led to his ouster in February 2004 following a rapid disintegration of public order.

Still viewed as a hero of the left, Aristide is in exile in South Africa. He is still considered to be the leader of his Fanmi Lavalas – the Flood party – currently barred from participating in the November elections.

The return of Aristide’s surrogates in Lavalas could easily trigger a new round of polarizing and violent politics. It could wreck the delicate process of rebuilding Haiti by unleashing suppressed anger and a desire for revenge.

Certainly Lavalas’ return to politics is supported by the American and international left. They consistently view Haiti and Aristide as victims, endlessly subjected to sinister forces from racial discrimination to capitalist exploitation. In the left’s book, Haiti remains a morality play between haves and have-nots, between privilege and social justice, with the United States and the West cast in the role of bad guys.

By opening old wounds and appealing to class politics, Lavalas candidates would trigger a sadly predictable chain of consequences.

Promising to remake Haiti from the bottom up, they would resort to land seizures, punitive taxes, and other draconian measures certain to trample rule of law, property rights and individual liberties.

Radicalization would spook foreign investors, leaving Haiti even more dependent on foreign assistance.

An Aristide-influenced Lavalas government would likely turn to Venezuela’s populist authoritarian Hugo Chavez to provide sufficient assistance – drawing it into his radical, anti-American camp. The 2009 removal of Honduras’ populist President Manuel Zelaya demonstrates where Chavez-led polarization can take a nation.

The United States cannot prevent the Haitian people from moving ahead with the Nov. 28 elections. It cannot say which candidate is right for Haiti.

It must state frankly, however, that it does not wish to see a fragile Haiti once more unraveled by the politics of division and hatred. It can send a clear signal that the return of Aristide’s Lavalas party would not be welcomed.

ABOUT THE WRITER

Ray Walser is the senior policy analyst specializing in Latin America at The Heritage Foundation. Readers may write to the author in care of The Heritage Foundation, 214 Massachusetts Avenue NE, Washington, D.C. 20002; Web site: www.heritage.org. Information about Heritage’s funding may be found at http://www.heritage.org/about/reports.cfm.

This essay is available to McClatchy-Tribune News Service subscribers. McClatchy-Tribune did not subsidize the writing of this column; the opinions are those of the writer and do not necessarily represent the views of McClatchy-Tribune or its editors.

—————————————————————————————————–

COMMENT: HAITIAN-TRUTH.ORG

QUOTE: “Seven months after the tragic Jan. 12 earthquake, Haiti is at last on the path to reconstruction. Thanks to a substantial flood of assistance…”

Why do I always feel that writers, like this, are talking about “somewhere else”??  There has been no path to reconstruction. The road is blocked with earthquake debris, and the actions of Preval, his government, and his circle of criminals.

Haiti’s future depends on how well its people can preserve political patience, mobilize massively to succeed and steer an essentially reformist course. A better Haiti requires sustained cooperation between rich, middle class and poor.

What’s with political patience.

DEMOCRACY HAS NO CALORIES!!!!

The Haitian masses have absolutely no faith in the Democratic Concept.

The need security, food, work, schools and, perhaps, some medical assistance.  They are disturbed by the in ability of the international community to help in these fields.  Their tarp shelters are beginning to fray and leak with each rain storm. They are disturbed to see jobs going to outsiders, when Haitians could do the work.

The foreigners euphemisms and endless planning are wasted time, so far as they are concerned.

Bill Clinton is a laugh. He has held one meeting, of his governing body, in five months.

People are starving to death.

We have disease and infection.

Schools are a joke.

Aristide, and Duvalier, remain potent political factors in the game and will continue to do so…on into the future.

Only a complete and total moron thinks that moral suasion will do anything to take Aristide out of the equation. He is a fact of life and people had best get that through their heads.

I am not an Aristide fan, but I am a realistic pragmatist.

Aristide will play an important role in the forthcoming games that – hopefully – will end with a really free-and-fair election, in spite of Preval’s efforts to poison the water.

I recall an old Pogo saying…for those old enough to recall this cartoon figure….

“I have seen the enemy and he are us…”

It is time for us to look in the mirror and develop a realistic approach to the Haitian problem that deals with it in a way fitting to the entire Haitian situation, and not one applicable to Southern California….or some other sophisticated sector of our advanced society.

Collins

Share:

Author: `

4 thoughts on “An Aristide government would put Haiti in Hugo Chavez camp-Added COMMENTARY By Haitian-Truth

  1. Very good, Collins!!

    These writers have never been to Haiti and form their opinion, based on facts gathered by other people who have never been to Haiti, or have agendas out of step with the Haitian reality.

    Foreigners may mean well but they never seem to deal with the real needs of my people.

    The needs are simple…they need law-and-order, work, food, school for the kids and some sort of medical service. They don’t expect much, just something a little better than exists.

    Most important, after jobs, is the ability for their children to get a decent education because this is the future of Haiti. We cannot waste these young children.

  2. The sad thing is…we had all of this with Jean-Claude Duvalier.

    And then the foreigners drove him out and it has been a disaster ever since.

    The blan always knows what is best for Haiti, even when they know nothing.

    Ambassador Sanderson was a real example of this. She was a real dummy with no understanding of my nation. I guess the needed to give her a job and Haiti’s chair was empty for her very large behind.

  3. Forget all of the other things.

    It is time for Preval to honor a Constitutional requirement and give Aristide his passport.

    It is neither fair nor legal to keep Aristide trapped in South Africa.

    I never voted for Aristide, but he was our President and deserves some respect..

  4. Serge makes a valid point about Haitians. Only God and Haitians know what Haitians need. I have never seen a people who need so little and never get anything.
    They would be so grateful for schoolsn medicine, a little food, and a place to sleep that is secure and dry! Haitians deserve a chance to decide what is good for them. There is too much money in this country for so many to still be in this misery.
    How those I charge of helping sleep at night I will never know. Oh yes, they sleep in nice rooms with AC and lights. Shame on all of you. You are not the saviors of the Haitian people, only their helpers.

Comments are closed.