U.S. brags Haiti response is a ‘model’ while more than a million remain homeless in Haiti

Over a month after the earthquake, hundreds of thousands of Haitians are still living in “sheet cities,” their only shelter made of bedsheets tied to tree branches serving as tent poles – and this is a model of “humanitarian aid delivery”? This camp is on a soccer field on the outskirts of Port au Prince, near the airport. For a closer look, click to enlarge this photo. – Photo: © LeMoyne, UNICEF

Despite the fact that over a million people remained homeless in Haiti one month after the earthquake, U.S. Ambassador to Haiti Ken Merten is quoted at a State Department briefing on Feb. 12, saying: “In terms of humanitarian aid delivery … frankly, it’s working really well. And I believe that this will be something that people will be able to look back on in the future as a model for how we’ve been able to sort ourselves out as donors on the ground and responding to an earthquake.”What? Haiti is a model of how the international government and donor community should respond to an earthquake? The ambassador must be overworked and need some R&R. Look at the facts:

The U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) reported Feb. 11 there are still 1.2 million people living in “spontaneous settlements” in and around Port au Prince as a result of the Jan. 12 earthquake. These spontaneous settlements are sprawling camps of homeless Haitian children and families living on the ground under sheets.

Over 300,000 are in camps in Carrefour, nearly 200,000 in Port au Prince, and over 100,000 each in Delmas, Petionville and Leogane, according to the U.N.

About 25,000 people are camped out on one golf course in Petionville. Hundreds of thousands of others are living in soccer fields, churchyards, on hillsides, in gullies and even on the strips of land in the middle of the street. The U.N. has identified over 300 such spontaneous settlements. The Red Cross reports there are over 700.

The U.N. reported that barely one in five of the people in camps have received tents or tarps as of Feb. 11. Eighty percent of the hundreds of thousands of children and families still live on the ground under sheets.

Many of these camps are huge. Nineteen of these homeless camps in the Port au Prince area together house 180,000 people. More than half of these camps are so spontaneous that there is no organization in the camp to even comprehensively report their needs.

Another half a million people have left Port au Prince, most to the countryside. As a result there are significant food problems in the countryside. About 168,000 internally displaced people are living along the border with the Dominican Republic. Many are with families. Others are in “spontaneous settlements” of up to a 1,000 people.

People living in these densely populated camps will be asked to move to more organized settlements outside the city. Relocation, says the U.N., will be on a voluntary basis.

The U.S. ambassador knows full well there are 900 or so aid agencies are on the ground in Haiti. Coordination and communication between those agencies and between them and the Haitian government continues to be a very serious challenge.

Though many people are trying hard to meet the survival needs in Haiti, no one besides the ambassador dares say that it is a model of how to respond. Partners in Health Director Dr. Louise Ivers reported on the very same day that “there is more and more misery” in Port au Prince as fears of typhoid and dysentery haunt the camps as the rainy season looms.

But still the Haitian spirit prevails. Everyone who has been to Haiti since the earthquake reports inspiring stories of Haitians helping Haitians despite the tragically inadequate response of the Haitian government and the international community. That spirit is something people should admire. Let me finish with a story that illustrates.

One orphanage outside of Port au Prince, home to 57 children, was promised a big tent so the children would no longer have to sleep under the stars. The tent arrived but without poles to hold it up. The same group was promised food from UNICEF. Twelve days later, no food had arrived. They improvised and constructed scaffolding to create an awning over the mattresses lying on the dirt. They are finding food from anywhere they can. “We’re holding on,” said the Haitian director, Etienne Bruny, “We’re used to difficult times.”

Haitians are holding on despite the inadequate humanitarian response. They are the model.

Bill Quigley is the legal director of the Center for Constitutional Rights and a frequent visitor to Haiti for human rights work over the past decade. You can reach him at Quigley77@gmail.com.


Author: `

3 thoughts on “U.S. brags Haiti response is a ‘model’ while more than a million remain homeless in Haiti

  1. For once Bill Quigley has hit the nail on the head. For a guy who is usually promoting bums like Jean-Juste he has written a really good article on the present situation in Haiti.

    Ambassador Merten has obviously been on another planet. We had hoped he would be some improvement over the previous American Ambassador Jeanette Sanderson who reminded many of a fat German housewife. She was also completely and totally disconnected with the Haitian reality.

    The new American Embassy is an impersonal fortress that allows its occupants to remain disconnected from the Haitian society. It even has a private community, built a couple of hundred yards away, in which Americans can live the same life they live in the States, with all of the amenities. Should they wish, they can spend their entire tours without ever meeting a Haitian, other than embassy staff members.

    The Haitian situation remains a disaster, with a small percentage of the victims living any sort of an acceptable condition.

    USAID has always been a dysfunctional organization, created to give employment to retired American government employees. If you want to squander money, give it to USAID. They once got involved in a coffee tree project and blew $5,000,000 without planting a single coffee tree. There is a lesson here.

    Haiti needs immediate and effective assistance to prevent an accelerating disaster on America’s doorstep. The coming rainy season is about to magnify the problems and show that Ambassador Merten had his head inserted in another part of his anatomy when he gave a thumbs up to the relief efforts.

  2. No need to be nasty to the handicapped.

    The American embassy is working to its limits, which – on a scale of 1 to 10 in the competitive private world – would rate a 1, unless fractions and negative quantities are allowed.

    Alvin Adams, and his predecessor Brunson McKinley, were the last real ambassadors from the States. What has followed must be viewed as an embarrassment, especially Brian Dean Curran who was the boyfriend/girlfriend of Haiti journalist Adyjeangardy.

    If this is the best the State Department has – we are in trouble. I can remember the comments by Kurt von Fischer, Austria’s Consul to Haiti. He once said..”The American Embassy in Haiti is the cesspool if the State Department.”… and that was in 1983.

    Let’s trade the embassy for 300 Marines without steel helmets, flak jackets and rifles.

    Things would turn around – Instantly!!

  3. Thank you for the sound critique. Me and my neighbor were just setting up to do some research about this. I am very glad to see such great info being shared freely out there.

Comments are closed.